HiFi Cookies has good cookies. Great cookies, even. But this year, owner Sean Newsome upped the shop’s game when he made cookie ice cream sandwiches a permanent part of the shop’s menu. The sandwiches — HiFi’s big, loaded cookies stuffed with a sizable scoop of ice cream — were something owner Newsome experimented with when the shop first opened in the spring of 2020, but for whatever reason, they never seemed to take off. Let’s blame our collective dumb pandemic brains for that; these ice cream cookie sandwiches are a marvel. Get the Marvin with salted caramel ice cream or the Buddy with strawberry ice cream. And it doesn’t stop at cookies! At one point Newsome even offered a Fruity Pebbles Rice Krispie Treat ice cream sandwich because there are no rules and no limits to what’s possible at HiFi Cookies. For extra indulgence, add a side of caramel or chocolate sauce to turn your sandwich into more of a sundae and embrace the messy cookie chaos.
Best Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich
