Just before 9 p.m. on Saturday, The 5 Spot was packed with faces sporting some combination of salt-and-pepper beards, shaggy forehead bangs and round tortoiseshell specs, crowded around tables overflowing with half-finished mugs of beer. It was an old-heads’ night out, a time to celebrate the Aughts glory days of the indie-rock scene that bounced between Murfreesboro and Nashville, courtesy of the recent reunion of Imaginary Baseball League.
Singer-songwriter-guitarist Aaron Robinson discusses the Nashville Aughts rock greats’ slow fade and surprise revival
For a brief window in the late 1990s, Middle Tennessee rock bands began to get noticed nationally, thanks in part to the buzz around Murfreesboro’s Spongebath Records and artists like Self, The Features, The Katies and Count Bass D. Though that attention cooled off somewhat in the early 2000s, bands coming up at that time like Imaginary Baseball League — consisting of frontman Aaron Robinson, multi-instrumentalist Keith Childrey, drummer Ryan Rayborn and original bassist Ben Evans, whose role WNXP program director Jason Moon Wilkins fills in the rebooted version — built up loyal fan bases that have withstood the decades.
On Saturday, the crowd at The 5 Spot was a blend of old friends and new fans, which might come as a bit of a surprise. But it makes sense when you consider that IBL’s 2004 debut album Revive is a time capsule of emotionally raw rock songs that stand up to the best writing any of their contemporaries were doing. “Aaron Robinson, you’re my hero,” someone screamed in a quiet moment during their set. You could tell they meant it.
Crystal Shrine at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Photo: Steve CrossMulti-instrumentalist and founding member of Those Darlins Kelley Anderson kicked things off, performing as Crystal Shrine. Though Anderson has lived elsewhere for more than a decade, her array of notable work around town — including as a co-founder of YEAH!, the nonprofit that’s been putting on youth rock camps in Nashville and Murfreesboro for more than two decades — continues to have an impact. During IBL’s set, Robinson recognized Anderson for a kind of relationship that plenty of people onstage and in the crowd had in common, saying: “I wanted to thank Kelley Anderson, my old post-college roommate, who let me bring a tiny dog into the house that wanted to pee on everything. Not sure she remembers that part, but I do.”
Anderson performed solo, her fingers moving up and down her blue-gray Fender Mustang in a way that felt like second nature. Her voice, sultry and smooth, flowed unhurried over plangent melodies that dissolved into rippling chaos between songs as she bent down to work her effects pedals. She told the crowd that many of the songs she played are from a project that’s not out yet, which she said deserves time to develop.
Punk Rock Party Band at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Photo: Steve CrossTo keep the party going, Punk Rock Party Band performed a set of covers that was … well, exactly what the name implies. The ensemble is full of Murfreesboro and Nashville OGs: singer-guitarist Joey Campbell, seldom seen onstage since the days of Turncoats; guitarist Linwood Regensburg, Anderson’s fellow onetime Darlin who took charge of getting Mama Zu’s Quilt Floor, his collaborative project with late bandmate Jessi Zazu, out into the world; bassist Bingham Barnes from Glossary, Electric Python and many more; and drummer Tyler Coppage, who you’ve seen with Hammertorch, Jasmin Kaset and others. Between lighthearted stage banter, the quartet played crunchy, scream-heavy punk tributes. They wrapped with a high-energy rendition of The Modern Lovers’ “Roadrunner” and a shoutout from Regensburg to long-gone ’Boro hangout The Red Rose Cafe.
The headliners went on a little later than anticipated, but started their set with the warbling drone of a single sustained note as Robinson crooned the start of “The One Infallible,” singing of long-ago longing that still resonates: “I used to stand outside the English wing / After second period / Just so I could see her walking by.”
Imaginary Baseball League at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Photo: Steve CrossRobinson’s singing and writing voices both have a good bit in common with Ben Gibbard in Death Cab for Cutie’s early years, with literate lyrics wrapped in an introspective vulnerability that makes soul-crushing narratives of love, loss and desperation ring true. In his thick-framed glasses and corduroy ball cap, Robinson stood onstage at The 5 Spot and let the emotion take over. His honeyed vocals strained as he played his Gretsch guitar so hard his right hand started bleeding. It didn’t faze him, and the group kept shredding feverishly through a set that included “Steeple to Steeple,” the Radiohead-esque opener of IBL’s long-shelved album The Inevitable Parting, finally released in 2021.
“This one is a little bit of a crowd-assistance situation,” Robinson said, introducing “A Lot to Say,” one of the most enduring songs in their catalog. “If you know it, then help. If you don’t, then help the people that are helping.” The refrain “Watch your mouth / Get you in trouble” has become a kind of tagline for Imaginary Baseball League, and even graces their Instagram bio. Robinson stood at the edge of the stage and conducted as practically the whole room sang the lines a cappella.
IBL ran a little long, ending after midnight, but the crowd didn’t seem to mind in the least. It was the kind of nostalgic experience that doesn’t leave you dreading going back out into the world, but instead just a little more prepared to deal with it.
The Spin: Imaginary Baseball League at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
With Crystal Shrine and Punk Rock Party Band
Imaginary Baseball League at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Imaginary Baseball League at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Imaginary Baseball League at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Imaginary Baseball League at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Imaginary Baseball League at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Imaginary Baseball League at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Imaginary Baseball League at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Imaginary Baseball League at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Imaginary Baseball League at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Imaginary Baseball League at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Imaginary Baseball League at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Imaginary Baseball League at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Imaginary Baseball League at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Imaginary Baseball League at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Imaginary Baseball League at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Imaginary Baseball League at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Imaginary Baseball League at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Imaginary Baseball League at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Crystal Shrine at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Crystal Shrine at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Crystal Shrine at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Crystal Shrine at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Crystal Shrine at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Punk Rock Party Band at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Punk Rock Party Band at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Punk Rock Party Band at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Punk Rock Party Band at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Punk Rock Party Band at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Punk Rock Party Band at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Punk Rock Party Band at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
Punk Rock Party Band at The 5 Spot, 11/14/2026
- Sean L. Maloney
- 10 min to read


Post a comment as anonymous
Report
Watch this discussion.
(0) comments
Welcome to the discussion.
Log In
Welcome to the discussion.
Keep it clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or otherwise abusive language. Comments featuring hate speech or threatening or violent content will not be tolerated.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Be truthful. Don't knowingly lie or mislead.
Be proactive. Use the “report” link on any comment that violates our comment policy.
Share with us. We'd love to hear your feedback.