Metropolitik is a recurring column featuring the Scene’s analysis of Metro dealings.
Good attorneys give the right advice even when it’s not what a client wants to hear.
“Now that the Tennessee Supreme Court has ruled on this question, there are no more legal challenges to mount,” opened Tyler Yarbro, the city’s new director of law, in a Friday afternoon presentation to Metro councilmembers. “You are now charged with the very difficult task of implementing this task and thus overhauling this legislative body.”
The Metro Council’s Charter Revision Committee doesn’t usually steal the spotlight. This month, it’s the jumping-off point for an uncharted journey as councilmembers plan to slash their own body by at least half, maybe more. Nashville doesn’t have too many moves left to make after four years of litigating against the state’s law setting 20-member limits for metropolitan governments’ legislative bodies. Many councilmembers, some weighing their own political futures, looked for a way out, probing legal options to avoid complete submission to the state legislature. Most of the council attended Friday’s meeting to game out scenarios with Yarbro, who spoke plainly to councilmembers — her clients, in a way, as she’s paid to argue on behalf of the body — as she shadowboxes potential lawsuits from city residents and state lawmakers.
Court also dismisses case challenging state takeover of Metro Nashville Airport Authority
The Tennessee General Assembly, state attorneys, the Tennessee Supreme Court and Yarbro seem to agree that the next move belongs to the Metro Council, which must now draft and pass a resolution describing its own evisceration from 40 members to a maximum of 20. But Yarbro, as opposed to state lawmakers, clarifies that this resolution must come alongside a proposed charter amendment that must go directly to Davidson County voters.
“I think the most faithful reading of the statute requires you to put this to the voters,” said Yarbro, fielding members’ questions. “I understand that some people read this differently, to say you can do this by resolution. I think that is a dangerous path, because it gives yourself powers that a faithful reading of the statute does not, in my opinion, give you.”
Scheduling is the tough part. The timeline is already tight; in a private conversation with the Scene, one councilmember called this moment the “precipice of chaos.” Council elections are scheduled for August 2027, so a special election — allowed by state law to amend the charter — would have to happen quickly.
Metro acts under the watchful eye of state lawmakers, who won a long-awaited, extensively litigated victory on Nov. 2 when the Tennessee Supreme Court ruled that Nashville’s council must observe a 20-member maximum, as passed by the Tennessee General Assembly in 2023 (and adjusted in 2025). This statute requires noncompliant local legislative bodies (Metro Council, for instance) to “take any legislative action required to effectuate” the cap. The law’s 2025 revision mandates this regardless of any charter provisions “to the contrary,” responding directly to a hangup Nashville attorneys have pointed out in court.
Even on the shortest potential timeline, the state’s crusade to cut the Metro Council will have been a four-year effort via two bills. A third might come early in the 2027 session to outline how, exactly, a government body reduces itself while complying with various guardrails. The Tennessee Supreme Court, state statute, the Tennessee Constitution, election law and the Metro Charter all have something relevant to say.
“If you are acting in good faith, taking a good-faith reading of the statute, trying to implement the law, you are a lawfully constituted body,” Yarbro cautioned on Nov. 13. “If you willfully ignore the order of the court — there’s a distinction there. If you decide not to implement this law or ignore the court’s ruling, then you run the risk of your votes being considered unenforceable or invalid, that this is not a lawfully constituted body that can carry out lawful activities.”
Over the next couple months, members are setting up listening sessions, conferring with consultants, planning more meetings and, eventually, agreeing on a bill to cut the council that will likely include directly amending the charter. They’re also jockeying for behind-the-scenes influence over the process.
The state’s GOP supermajority has spent years pushing the legal boundary between its lawmaking authority and Nashville’s, losing at first before refining strategies that have delivered durable wins for the state. This recent legal opinion places the city charter, Nashville’s essential document, firmly under state law. The coming council reduction also shows Tennessee lawmakers directly controlling Nashville, a psychological breach as much as a political one.
Metropolitik: A pending opinion from the Tennessee Supreme Court could define 2027 elections
“That’s a bad day for Nashville — that’s a bad day for self-government in Tennessee,” said District 6 Councilmember Clay Capp, describing the legal opinion to members of the council’s Charter Revision Committee, which he chairs. “That’s a bad day for our sister counties and municipalities as well when it comes to their protection from state overreach, protection that should be in the constitution.”
Politics played out amid Friday’s legalese as members realized the importance of the chamber’s next steps. At some point soon, a new map of Metro Council districts will emerge. Redrawn and consolidated districts will determine many current members’ survival into another term. Capp, a first-term councilmember, was influencing his own political future while wielding Friday’s gavel, and assured his colleagues that the process will be accessible. Some pressed Vice Mayor Angie Henderson about consultants from global professional services firm Accenture, hired to study other local governments and report back on city council best practices.
“All councilmembers should consider themselves invited to all of this,” Capp reminded his colleagues.
In another worst-case scenario, District 29’s Tasha Ellis speculated that the state could write its own maps to go into place should Metro Council fail to deliver something promptly. Yarbro pointed out that this would almost certainly violate Nashville’s scant constitutional protections against targeted lawmaking, but the mere suggestion shows how this law (and others like it) have eliminated trust between the Metro Council and the Tennessee General Assembly, separated by just a half-mile.


Post a comment as anonymous
Report
Watch this discussion.
(0) comments
Welcome to the discussion.
Log In
Welcome to the discussion.
Keep it clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or otherwise abusive language. Comments featuring hate speech or threatening or violent content will not be tolerated.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Be truthful. Don't knowingly lie or mislead.
Be proactive. Use the “report” link on any comment that violates our comment policy.
Share with us. We'd love to hear your feedback.