Months before state legislators gavel into session, they are already controlling Nashville’s 40-member Metro Council. City officials are sprinting to reduce their own chamber’s size to comply with the state’s 20-person cap on local legislative bodies, fearing further lawsuits if the state isn’t satisfied with their pace. At a meeting on Wednesday — the Metro Council’s second Charter Revision Committee meeting in six days — councilmembers planned seven more meetings in the next month to prepare the city government overhaul.
Five community events will seek feedback and opinions from residents, who can choose between Dec. 3, Dec. 7, Dec. 8 and Dec. 12. Councilmembers are wary to make these events an “open mic night,” as the legal reality of reducing the body was settled by a Tennessee Supreme Court opinion issued Nov. 2. Members do want to hear citizens’ opinions on the size and composition of their local government as the Metro Council drafts law to reconstitute itself. On Wednesday evening, debate already flared up among viewers in the meeting’s online YouTube chat.
Court also dismisses case challenging state takeover of Metro Nashville Airport Authority
“There’s nothing we can do with regards to the law,” Councilmember At-Large Zulfat Suara reminded her colleagues (and the public). “The biggest thing we need from the community is the composition. That’s the biggest thing we need from them. We can complain all day — I don’t like it — but there’s nothing we can do with that.”
Four meetings will be at public spaces around the county, while the council chamber downtown will host on Dec. 7. The committee steering the process will meet again to finalize information before its public push on Monday, Nov. 30, then again on Monday, Dec. 14, after the county tour.
Councilmembers are now scrambling to get organized on two fronts. First, whether they need to push a ballot referendum alongside a resolution reorganizing the Metro Council under the state’s 20-person cap. Second, how exactly they want to compose a new council in both geography and size.
During a legal briefing from the city’s top attorney Tyler Yarbro last week, members of the committee planned to craft a bill cutting the council while simultaneously reconciling the changes with the city charter. This would take a direct referendum vote, likely demanding a special election in the spring, adding delays and potential complications before the city elects councilmembers again in August.
District 26 Councilmember Courtney Johnston favored moving quickly with a resolution; adding a referendum could frustrate state lawmakers, she said, especially if it were to fail.
“I really think we ought to proceed with caution here and really think long and hard about what we’re walking into,” Johnston told colleagues. “I don’t think this is what we want to do to ourselves. Everybody knows they are probably watching — watching how we are handling this. I do think they very much disagree with Director Yarbro’s advice. There’s other things the state can do to make this so much worse.”
Metropolitik: Tyler Yarbro, the city’s new top attorney, steers Metro through uncharted territory
While other members acknowledged the fear, many preferred to stick with their lawyer. Committee Chair Clay Capp, quoting U.S. Supreme Court Justice Neil Gorsuch, argued that “only the written word is the law” — not any hypothetical intent from state lawmakers.
“For us to preempt ourselves, even before the state chimes in officially, is a disservice to Nashville, in my own opinion,” Suara stated. “I hope they’re not going to retaliate knowing we’re doing all that we can with what we got and acting as best as we can.”
Wednesday’s evening session already tested members’ meeting tolerance. While these local officials debated in circles, they missed participating in the National League of Cities conference downtown. (Councilmember At-Large Burkley Allen still wore her NLC lanyard in the chamber.) Interlocking issues surfaced as members weighed legal and practical debates of their task, prompting a summary quip from District 5 Councilmember Sean Parker that soon brought the meeting to an end.
“I’m doing my very best not to provoke debate tonight,” Parker said, drawing agreement from Chair Capp. “I really don’t think we have the steam for it. I think it would be better handled in our work sessions.”


Post a comment as anonymous
Report
Watch this discussion.
(0) comments
Welcome to the discussion.
Log In
Welcome to the discussion.
Keep it clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or otherwise abusive language. Comments featuring hate speech or threatening or violent content will not be tolerated.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Be truthful. Don't knowingly lie or mislead.
Be proactive. Use the “report” link on any comment that violates our comment policy.
Share with us. We'd love to hear your feedback.