Thanks to Susan Mulcahy at the New York Times, we now learn that Fisk University’s cultural theft from its students is worse than we knew. While we were fighting over the Stieglitz Collection, Fisk was selling two other prize paintings:
But what was not revealed at the time, and has only recently come to light, is that before the agreement was completed — and with the debate over the future of Fisk itself swirling around her — Hazel O’Leary, then the university’s president, on behalf of the school quietly sold off two other paintings owned by Fisk.The institution was “under duress,” said Patrick Albano of Aaron Galleries, an art dealer from Illinois whom Ms. O’Leary asked to broker the sale.
Emily Siner at WPLN has further details:
Ken West, a former Fisk spokesman who worked closely with O'Leary, says he doesn't believe it was intentionally kept quiet."It might be new to some, but it's definitely not new, and I don't think it's earth-shattering if you consider the financial condition the university was in at the time," he says.
Universities often come under fire by the art world for selling high-dollar possessions when they're in financial trouble. West says that point of view lacks context.
"It's one thing to say, 'Don't sell the painting because it has a rich tradition and it's very important' — and that's very true," he says. "But I want the same people who are critical to tell these first-generation students that they can't come back next year because there are no funds to provide them a scholarship."
West calls the decision to sell these paintings a "last resort."
This is just terrible. First of all, Fisk’s financial crisis didn’t come out of nowhere all of a sudden. A lot of people going back a long, long way should be taking a hard look at themselves in the mirror, because the fact that Fisk was in bad enough straits to sell these paintings is a testament to years of screwing up.
Second, and most important, those paintings — all the art at Fisk — belong to the whole of Fisk University. The paintings are to further the education of Fisk’s students, not to be used as the credit card the administration keeps in a block of ice in the freezer for real emergencies. That Ken West would even remotely phrase this as some kind of choice between the art and the students is just vile and heartbreaking. Those paintings were for the students, first-generation students included, to see, appreciate, study, and value and the administration at Fisk, in order to cover up their financial bumbling, stole those paintings from the students.
Maybe by the time it was done, it was the only “good” choice. I’m sure the mother who sneaks into her kid’s room to loot the kid’s piggy bank for grocery money also feels like it’s her only good choice. But when you’ve reached a point where you have to steal from the people you’ve been entrusted to take care of, your “good” choice is pretty damn bad.
Fisk’s value is its extraordinary legacy. You go into the chapel and you’re sitting in the same seats the people who changed the world in the ‘60s sat in. You scurry across the lawn, late for class, you’re stepping on the same ground John Work scurried across, recordings of Muddy Waters tucked under his arms. You stand in front of a painting in the Stieglitz Collection and you’re seeing the same art Georgia O’Keefe marvelled at. The promise of Fisk is that, by attending this institution, you’ll be taking your place in that grand legacy.
How much of what’s special about Fisk can you remove to “save” Fisk and still have an institution worth saving?


Post a comment as anonymous
Report
Watch this discussion.
(0) comments
Welcome to the discussion.
Log In
Welcome to the discussion.
Keep it clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or otherwise abusive language. Comments featuring hate speech or threatening or violent content will not be tolerated.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Be truthful. Don't knowingly lie or mislead.
Be proactive. Use the “report” link on any comment that violates our comment policy.
Share with us. We'd love to hear your feedback.