Becker’s Bakery

2600 12th Ave. S. 383-5554

Hours: 9 a.m.-5 p.m. Tues.-Sat.

“I’m really not a sweet person,” Bethe Becker says as she sits at a small wooden table under shelves loaded with wedding cake toppers in the front room of Becker’s Bakery. She is not speaking of her personality, which is warm, friendly, and outgoing, but of her tastes in food.

This confession from the wife of the third generation of Becker men to own and operate one of Nashville’s most enduring and beloved food service institutions might be akin to the spouse of Pepsi’s CEO revealing that she only drinks Coke. But Bethe Becker adds one caveat to her anti-testimonial: “Well, I do love the white cake with white icing,” she admits. “I could eat that all day long. There is no better icing in Nashville than ours.”

The thousands of customers who have been ordering Becker’s Bakery cakes would say amen to that. (White cake with white frosting is the number-one choice.) Though prebaked and prepackaged supermarket cakes have given the Becker family a run for their money, Becker’s Bakery and birthday cakes are as intrinsically bound to one another as Roy Acuff and the Grand Ole Opry.

So much so that, in 1963, Life & Casualty Insurance Company—another grand old Nashville tradition—commissioned Becker’s to design, bake, construct, and assemble a scale replica of downtown’s first skyscraper to celebrate the company’s 60th birthday. The task fell to Frank Becker Sr. and his brother Tom Becker; they consulted with Avco Corp. Frank’s father-in-law, John Suter, drew up the blueprints, and Avco engineers constructed the steel platforms and support columns necessary for the project.

The 18-foot-high, 5,400-pound model of the 31-story building took six days to bake, build, and assemble. The 540 layers required 2,463 pounds of sugar, 1,258 pounds of flour, 54 pounds of baking powder, 17 pounds of salt, 536 pounds of shortening, 288 pounds of butter, 12 quarts of vanilla, 100 gallons of milk, and 14,000 eggs. The cake was valued at $3,700. It is said that all of Nashville came downtown to see the unveiling of the monstrous confection, and all who showed up were rewarded with a piece of birthday cake. As the largest cake ever made in its time, photos and stories about the ultimate Becker’s birthday cake received national coverage. But the Beckers’ light has always shined brightest in their own hometown, and that’s the way they like it.

Frank Anderson Becker (grandfather of the current owner, Frank Jr.) and Frank Neiderhauser (whose family at one time owned much of the land that is now Green Hills) opened Becker’s Bakery in 1925 in the same location it is now—the corner of 12th Avenue South and Montrose. The business began as a nickel-loaf bakery; the 5-cent loaves of bread were loaded onto the store truck and delivered to wholesale customers. When the Depression struck, Becker and Neiderhauser borrowed Marie Antoinette’s infamous phrase and began selling small white cakes they called Mrs. Becker’s Little Cakes. “It helped get them through the Depression,” says Frank Jr.

Frank Becker’s sons, Frank Sr. (known to everyone as Nicky) and Tom, began working in the family business when they were just 5 years old. During the school year, the Becker’s truck picked them up at school, and they took up their positions in the back, jumping off to make deliveries.

The business grew during World War II, thanks in large part to the rationing required by every household. “Somehow, my grandfather was able to get sugar, and they began baking birthday cakes,” says Frank Jr. “That’s how our retail operation really took hold.”

Through the years, as the bakery’s line of sweets grew—more cakes, cupcakes, brownies, pies, tarts, cookies, and pastries—the loaves of bread were gradually phased out, replaced by dinner rolls, biscuits, and corn muffins. In 1964, Nicky and Tom Becker took over the store. And like his father before him, Frank Jr. began working there at a young age, though primarily during the hectic holiday season. “Every year from the time I started school, as soon as school let out for the Christmas holiday until the store closed on Christmas Eve, I was in here packing bags of rolls, 24 to a bag, all day long.”

The experience did not propel him into the family business. Instead, he became a cop, which is where he met Bethe, then working in dispatch. The couple were married 11 years ago; Frank Jr.’s mother, Jane, baked the wedding cake. “It’s the first time I ever saw her do the whole wedding cake herself, but she really wanted to do it,” he says. “I didn’t get to pick anything but the topper,” Bethe adds with a laugh.

Tom Becker passed away in 1993. Not long afterward, Nicky Becker needed surgery, so Frank Jr. began helping out down at the store; it soon became clear that he would have to take over. “I think my father would have shut the doors before selling the bakery out of the family,” Frank Jr. says. “If he were ever going to be able to retire, we had to take it over. It’s not just a business, it’s a tradition, and we respect and honor that tradition.”

Frank Jr. left the police force first—Bethe was pregnant with twins at the time—and worked alongside his dad for about a year before taking over completely in January 1995. These days, Nicky comes in every once in a while for a quality-control check, and he orders his usual: a chocolate meringue tart and diet Coke.

“It was an easy transition,” Frank Jr. says. “There were few surprises.” He already knew that work begins every day about 5:30 a.m., when the three full-time bakers and one assistant start making the pie dough and mixing the fillings and cake batters. Mixing and baking takes place in one large back room dominated by large ovens and mixers more than 60 years old; icing and decorating takes place in the other back room.

Pies and cakes are carefully set on racks behind the counter, cookies and pastries are placed in the ancient wooden bakery cases, and bagged rolls go on another rack. The doors open at 9 a.m. Tuesday through Saturday and close on the dot at 5 p.m. Two full-time counter people and five part-timers take orders, weigh cookies, and place cakes and pies in the traditional white cardboard bakery boxes.

The busiest times of the year are Thanksgiving and Christmas, when bakers typically begin reporting to work at about 2:30 in the morning and staying until 8 at night. On the Wednesday before Thanksgiving and on Christmas Eve, Becker’s opens the doors at 8 a.m. to accommodate customers who begin lining up as early as 6 o’clock. “We get everybody,” Bethe says. “One year, Reba McEntire was standing out there in line, just like everybody else.”

The biggest sellers at Christmas are coconut cakes and Castleberry rolls. At Thanksgiving, they’re pumpkin pies and Parker House rolls; on the Wednesday before Thanksgiving, Becker’s sells between 800 and 1,000 pumpkin pies. The most popular pie is chocolate meringue. “We are not welcome at our friends’ houses unless we bring a chocolate meringue pie,” Bethe says.

For decades, the favorite cookie has been the fancy colored wafer, at $4.99 a pound. The tradition of giving children a free wafer was begun during Frank Anderson Becker’s time, with a counter woman named Miss Mary. “She worked here for eons,” Frank Jr. says. “Lots of people thought she owned the place.” Some customers, now grandparents bringing in their own grandkids, still ask about Miss Mary.

Though the recipe is the same for every wafer—the only exception being the food coloring used to dye the dough—some people swear they can taste a difference and will only order one color. For Halloween, the bakers color some wafers a deep orange, and for Christmas, they color them a deep green and red.

The popularity of the Tennessee Titans football game has even affected Becker’s Bakery. “We have one customer who asked if during the season we could make blue-and-red Titans-colored wafers,” Frank Jr. says. “We started doing that the first season they played here. One week we didn’t make them, and the Titans lost that Sunday. That customer was so upset, he was sure it was all our fault. We have never done that again!”

After they took over the business, Frank and Bethe added a gourmet line of cookies, and very soon, they’ll be selling their own bleu cheese dressing at the store. Other than that, the product line and recipes have remained unchanged for years.

Still, some alterations have been made. Soon after taking over the store, at Bethe’s request, the light-blue walls were painted yellow, which caused a little grumbling among veteran customers. Then the center racks were moved to the side of the store to create a better flow, and a cooler case with soft drinks was added, which also raised some concern. In 1996, the store began, for the first time in 70 years, taking checks. That too caused some anxiety. “People love this place the way it is, and we have found that any change at all causes concern that everything will change,” Bethe explains.

Frank Jr. says that as long as a Becker is behind the counter, that won’t happen. “Our customers can see me pulling a cake out of our ovens if they want to,” he says. “They won’t see that at a grocery store. Here, with every single thing we sell, I know who mixed it, who baked it, who iced it, who decorated it, who boxed it and sold it. That’s what makes us who we are.”

Like what you read?


Click here to become a member of the Scene !


Load comments