In Catholic traditions, particularly in Italy, worshippers eschew eating meat on what are known as the vigil days preceding major religious festivals. Christmas Eve is regarded as one of those days, so what is a self-respecting Italian family supposed to do when everybody is over to the house but meat is off the menu? Why, load up the table with seafood dishes, of course.

That’s the idea behind the traditional Feast of the Seven Fishes, also known as La Vigilia (“The Vigil”). The concept was introduced to the United States in the late 19th century by Italian American immigrants who celebrated the coming of Christmas with huge family meals featuring at least seven seafood dishes. With the feast not limited to just Catholic families anymore, two Nashville restaurants are offering their own versions this year, each in a novel way.

Chef Nick Pellegrino will invite feasters into Mangia Nashville in Melrose on Dec. 23 for a re-creation of the Seven Fishes meals of his youth. It will be a convivial (and socially distanced) gathering of friends and family to enjoy five courses of dishes made from Pellegrino family recipes passed through the generations.

At Nicky’s Coal Fired, Caroline and Tony Galzin realize that not everyone is ready to dine in a restaurant yet. But they don’t want you to miss out on the Seven Fishes experience, so they’ve devised a mobile version of the feast with your choice of four or the full complement of seven fishes prepared to carry home on Christmas Eve and reheat with your family.

No matter which feast experience you might choose, you’ll be taking part in a tradition that means a lot to all the chefs involved. “I was the first one to do this thing in 2011,” Pellegrino says. “I remember saying, ‘I’m doing the Feast of Seven Fishes,’ and people were like, ‘What is that?’ And then all the Italians started coming out of the woodwork saying, ‘Wait a minute! You’re doing the Feast?’ I did it every Saturday for the month of December.”

In fact, it was Pellegrino’s childhood memories of the Feast of the Seven Fishes that inspired Mangia’s signature weekend feasts — a joyous multicourse dinner party served family-style to tables of friends and strangers who would soon become friends, accompanied by music and dancing between courses — earlier that year. “This meal, for me as an Italian American growing up in New York with a big family, was the pinnacle of your year,” Pellegrino says. “I wanted this more than I wanted G.I. Joes under the tree when I woke up. You’d get in my grandma’s basement apartment, and there were literally 40 of us around one big table, jammed in there. My grandmother and my aunts would prepare food for a week. I remember my grandmother had live eels in her bathtub! My Uncle Vinnie would go to the Fulton Fish Market and buy live eels, and they’d kill them and cook them. I was like, ‘What the hell is this?!’ It was insanity! I’m not doing that, but I always tell people that the biggest inspiration for my business was sharing this meal.”

Pellegrino loves that he can keep his family traditions alive and share them with Nashville. “I’m doing a lot of my grandma’s recipes,” he says. “She’d make baccalà four different ways, and people don’t think they’ll like salt cod. I make baccalà mantecato, and that’s the kind of dish that if you don’t prepare it properly, people are going to be turned off to that forever. But if you do it the right way, if you pull enough of the salt out of it, it’s just so good! We put it on grilled polenta, and it’s whipped up with heavy cream and a little bit of garlic. It’s crazy. I’ll eat that for three days after the Feast. Just sit there in my chair with a glass of Scotch and eat that stuff!”

Pellegrino’s take on the Feast of the Seven Fishes is unique to him, and there’s no set menu for the tradition. “Everybody has their own version,” he says. “It’s really a Southern Italian thing, and a lot of my Northern Italian friends never did it. On Christmas Eve, you’re not supposed to eat meat until after midnight, and the Southern Italians said, ‘We live right on the coast with all this beautiful seafood, so we’re gonna do that.’ Italian Americans evolved that into seven fish. I was brought up to understand that the seven fish represented each of the sacraments of the Catholic Church. Now, we always had more than seven, but you can’t have less. No way can you have less!”

The Mangia Nashville menu features an antipasti course of roasted garlic and black carbon focaccia, plus the baccalà, grilled baby octopus and crab cakes. That course is followed by a cold seafood salad and then the primo — lobster risotto and a plate of penne served with the Pellegrino family pasta sauce. “It’s really kind of like a puttanesca sauce, and my grandmother would put golden raisins into that sauce,” says Pellegrino. “So it would have a little sweetness in there with all the saltiness and brininess of the puttanesca.”

The showstopper comes during the secondo course. There’s a shrimp scampi platter, but as Pellegrino explains: “The pinnacle of the meal is when you come out and everybody gets a whole red snapper. The cavity of the fish is stuffed with oranges and fennel and red onion, and it’s really nice to see people’s faces when the whole fish comes to the table. We’ll finish it off with a panettone that I make and some chocolate truffles.”

Pellegrino is very excited about this opportunity to share his traditions, especially after a tough year in the restaurant business that has seen him working the kitchen all by himself at times during his Saturday feasts. “This is the menu that I love, and we’ve had people coming since 2011 who have made it part of their holiday tradition,” he says. “For me, that’s the greatest compliment that I could ever get. They love this thing so much that they make it a point to be there for it.”

Tony Galzin also grew up eating the Feast with his Italian family in Chicago. “Tony’s family always does the Feast, and they are some of our best holiday memories with family,” recalls his wife Caroline. “There’s a huge fish wholesaler on the way out to Tony’s mom’s house, so we’d stop to pick up lobsters and various seafood items. I will say that if we celebrated the holidays with a little too much late-night pre-Christmas partying, waking up first thing in the morning and going to a fish wholesaler is not the ideal environment for a holiday hangover!”

Tony recalls cooking with his family and their rules, saying: “My family doesn’t always do exactly seven fishes, but if I’m around, we’ve got seven plus different fishes. There are some traditional things, like the salt cod fritters and usually a pasta with clams or shrimp. We always do a lobster risotto, which isn’t super Italian-traditional, but it is for us. It’s always a big spread.”

Caroline explains what they’ve created for the Nicky’s Coal Fired offering: “We came up with a Four Fishes at Home package in case seven fishes sounds like, well, a lot of fishes to you. Tony designed the menu keeping in mind that seafood isn’t always the easiest to reheat, so we were mindful of what we thought would hold and be really delicious as a to-go experience.”

Diners can order online at nickysnashville.com by Saturday, Dec. 19, to pick up either a Four Fishes at Home Package or a Seven Fishes meal for two or four diners, and schedule a pickup time on Christmas Eve. Each meal will come packed in containers with reheating instructions to create a restaurant-quality meal at home. The Four Fishes Feast includes lobster risotto, baked clams, fruta di mare and baccalà fritters plus chocolate/orange/ricotta cannoli for dessert.

“I’m suggesting that people order extra cannoli,” Caroline says, “and most of them are, because they’re so good!” Diners who opt for the full Feast of the Seven Fishes will also find stuffed squid, mussel bruschetta and house-made spaghetti with shrimp and bay scallops in a tomato-garlic sauce as additions to their package.

“We’ve had a great response, but we’ve still got room for more orders,” says Caroline. “A lot of people are rethinking Christmas gifts this year because it’s been such a challenging year, and this is a great way to support a local small business. Plus you can enjoy a great meal together virtually.”

Like what you read?


Click here to become a member of the Scene !


Load comments