Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping

Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping

We live in a different world than the one The Hunger Games was released into in 2008. Since then, Suzanne Collins’ young-adult battle royale trilogy has birthed a subgenre of teen dystopian fiction and been adapted into four movies — and now, a new series of prequels. The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes, its first installment, begs sympathy for the dictator, following a young Coriolanus Snow as he tries to protect competitor Lucy Gray Baird on his way to becoming a tyrant.

Sunrise on the Reaping — the follow-up, with a film adaptation out Friday — finds an easier target for compassion in Haymitch Abernathy, the drunken victor who later coaches Katniss Everdeen. In the Midsommar-esque woodland landscape of his own Games, a young Haymitch is played by Joseph Zada, whose sad blue eyes poignantly capture the weight of the world closing in on him. The film is a definite improvement over Songbirds, with compelling action sequences and lovable characters. But as with its protagonist, Sunrise’s fundamental problem is that it just doesn’t trust itself.

Plot-wise, Sunrise on the Reaping is often too neat  — and some of its layers undercut The Hunger Games’ impact. Haymitch can’t just be a traumatized alcoholic; he also has to have a backstory as a moonshiner. Instead of being inspired by Katniss’ groundswell, adult characters in the original trilogy’s resistance have always been quiet revolutionaries. The film’s dialogue, meanwhile, meanders into overkill. At one point, Ralph Fiennes’ President Snow answers bad news this way: “Arrest everyone with whom the boy had contact. And trigger the volcano.” In a superheroic monologue toward the end, Haymitch promises, “I’ll be the worst victor in history ... but I’ll never stop” — a bizarre resilience that rings false compared to the version of the character we meet as an adult.

Other additions break the series’ mold instead of contorting within it, and these are the most interesting to watch. District 12’s Louella McCoy is held up as a stand-in for Rue, the innocent Katniss tries to protect, but a freak twist reveals how bizarre the Capitol’s workings can be. A refreshing sense of humor marks the film, particularly provided by Zada. Interestingly, the central Hunger Games competitors in both prequels have broken the bounds of the setting itself: Lucy Gray descends into the sewers of her arena in Songbirds, and in Sunrise, Haymitch sneaks into the underground network below his own to trigger a flood.

It’s as if these stories are literally straining against the confines of their cinematic universe — and the unpleasant contradiction that its commentary on media and violence may have been subsumed into more bread and circuses. After my device-free screening, a throng of people gathered around the phone-check table, waiting patiently for their names to be called. It felt a little too familiar.

Like what you read?


Click here to become a member of the Scene !


Load comments