Will the State Legislature Let Nashville's Short-Term Rental Rules Stand?

Members of Nashville’s Metro Council weren’t oblivious last week when they passed new restrictions on short-term renting in residential neighborhoods. They knew that the legislative body located just a few blocks from their chambers could very well strike down the new Nashville regulations, eliminating or hampering the city’s ability to proactively police Airbnbs and rentals like them.

It’s a constant threat for the Metro Council — that the conservative Tennessee General Assembly will step in and reverse Nashville’s own (often progressive) legislative efforts.

District 26 Councilmember Jeremy Elrod, whose day job is as a lobbyist at the state legislature, warned his fellow councilmembers about the prospect of pre-emption as they debated the new short-term rental regulations last week.

“As a local official, I would like to make decisions for Nashville in Nashville, but sometimes that’s not the way it is,” Elrod said after the vote. “The federal government sometimes tells Tennessee what to do, and sometimes Tennessee tells local governments what to do. And we just have to work within that framework.”

Elrod suggested passing compromise legislation more friendly to the rental industry — because, he said, it might be less likely to invoke the scrutiny of the legislature and lead to pre-emption.

But District 19 Councilmember Freddie O’Connell disagreed, saying that legislating specifically to avoid pre-emption is indefensible.

“We are not the General Assembly,” said O’Connell during debate over the bills. “If we do something that offends the General Assembly, they do reserve the right to pre-empt us. But we should not give them the satisfaction of doing their jobs for them.”

Legislation is already working its way through the General Assembly that would strictly limit Tennessee cities’ ability to regulate Airbnbs and other short-term rentals. It passed the House last year, and its Senate sponsor, Sen. John Stevens (R-Huntingdon), says he plans to push for passage again this session.

In fact, he said, he is considering adding language that would force cities that restrict short-term rentals to financially compensate property owners. The original legislation was crafted with input from rental platforms, and an Airbnb spokesperson touted the possibility of pre-emption in a defiant statement released after the Metro Council passed their regulations. 

Stevens called Nashville’s regulations theft.

“I’m not trying to overly interfere with the proper zoning and planning, but from a state perspective, we have to look at good public policy as a state,” he said. “And from an economic standpoint … what Nashville is proposing to do, it’s theft.

“These people bought something, played by the rules, and Nashville is going to take away the value of what they bought,” he added. “And they’re not going to give them any compensation for it.”

In recent years, the legislature has pre-empted Nashville on a number of issues, both practical and symbolic, including marijuana, gas-compressor stations and nondiscrimination ordinances. But Metro officials also point to some instances in which the two politically divergent bodies have found common ground — including, notably, last year’s IMPROVE Act, which paved the way for Mayor Megan Barry’s multibillion-dollar transit initiative. 

“While pre-emption, or the threat of pre-emption, is something we have had to deal with in the past, we have also been able to work positively with Governor Haslam and the State Legislature to pass important legislation like the IMPROVE Act which benefits Nashville’s residents,” Barry spokesperson Sean Braisted said in a statement. “As the legislative session progresses, we will work with our government relations team to identify and monitor any legislation that could positively or negatively impact Nashville, and share thoughts, concerns or suggestions with sponsors, committee members and other members of the Tennessee General Assembly as necessary.”

Like what you read?


Click here to become a member of the Scene !


Load comments