The notion that insurgent country music functions as a corrective to mainstream country remains, somewhat paradoxically, a powerful one. Sarah Shook’s new full-length, Years, embodies the contradictory impulses of modern country, but it doesn’t traffic in any obvious paradoxes or conflicts. In every essential way, the New York-born Shook is a stone country vocalist who twists her lyrics into a deadpan Americanese that’s both singerly and eccentric. Her efficient band, The Disarmers, backs her in a rock-meets-country fashion that’s far from insurgent, and it’s Shook’s relationship songs — and her detailed singing — that make Years something more than standard alt-rock-country. Shook’s new music gropes toward pop, which may be the most insurgent move Shook could make.
Shook cut Years in Pittsboro, N.C., with producer Ian Schreier at Manifold Recording. Schreier, who also engineered and mixed Years, caught the sound of a raucous country-rock band that had honed its approach on the road. Having garnered attention for her 2015 debut full-length Sidelong, Shook received even more alt-country props when well-known Americana label Bloodshot reissued the album two years later.
“When we made Sidelong, we hadn’t been together for very long,” Shook tells the Scene from a tour stop in Sweden. “So when we went into the studio to make Years, we had some heavy-duty touring under our belts. We became a lot more cohesive as a band.”
Shook, who was born in Rochester, N.Y., in 1985, writes with poetic cohesion throughout Years, which draws some of its power from the stylizations of Shook’s band. In some ways, Years is a typical Bloodshot release — the rock is a bit pro forma, and the band uses a country-pop-rock idiom that grafts the aesthetic of 1987, or 1997, onto country music as it was played in 1970. Drummer John Howie Jr. keeps the music skipping along in the mode of Old 97’s, and Eric Peterson’s guitar fills come straight out of the country-rock book.
If Shook’s band does an admirable job of translating her ideas into music that alt-country fans can identify with, she is a very individualistic singer who comes across as a post-Elliott Smith, post-emo and post-insurgent-country vocalist of intermittent genius. Shook sings the Years song “Damned If I Do, Damned If I Don’t” in exemplary rockabilly fashion, and she takes country melisma to new levels on the record’s title track, where she stretches “years” into five eccentrically sung syllables. Shook is a funny, self-deprecating and humorously self-righteous singer who fits comfortably into the continuum of classic country vocalists, but she claims to be completely uninfluenced by Tammy Wynette, Loretta Lynn and Jeannie Seely.
“I’ve never been influenced,” Shook tells the Scene. “It’s weird, because the only reason I started singing, and the only reason I started playing guitar, was for the sole purpose of having something to put my lyrics to. Finding my voice and learning guitar was just like a vehicle for this thing that was very cathartic and very life-affirming.”
What’s striking about Shook’s songwriting on Years is how unaffectedly a country artist who’s in some ways anarchic rewrites the genre’s tropes. In “Good as Gold” Shook sings: “It seems my way of livin’ don’t line up to your standards / If you had your way I’d be some proper kind of lady.” Meanwhile, Shook stands up for personal authenticity in the psychobilly-flavored “The Bottle Never Lets Me Down,” in which she favors drinking over a relationship.
If Shook’s new music rewrites the conventional narratives of country for an era of radical democracy, she remains a product of old-fashioned American repression, a component of country that she seems aware of. “I was raised very, very traditional, conservative Christian,” says Shook. “I was taught my entire existence that the only reason I existed as a woman or a female was to be a wife, mother and housekeeper.”
Shook has shed her allegiance to the limited world of suburban bliss that Tammy Wynette’s music exemplified, but she shares Wynette’s idealism and romantic notions about relationships. Years is a complex, subtle and well-wrought record about the tension between radical democracy and the necessity of meaningful relationships. Shook’s vocals are funny, self-aware and a little self-mocking, a tone that suits her songwriting perfectly.
Talking to Shook, I perceive a tough intelligence at work. She quotes Albert Camus, makes cogent remarks about the necessity of transcending belief systems, and disavows political intentions in her music with the serene air of a born politician. Far from being an example of avant-garde country, Years is Shook’s meditation on the way time can ravage a relationship, and the importance of self-definition in a world that can tear you to pieces if you aren’t careful. Like all great country artists, Shook understands the allure of repression, and she’s trying to figure out her own way of dealing with it.


Post a comment as anonymous
Report
Watch this discussion.
(0) comments
Welcome to the discussion.
Log In
Welcome to the discussion.
Keep it clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or otherwise abusive language. Comments featuring hate speech or threatening or violent content will not be tolerated.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Be truthful. Don't knowingly lie or mislead.
Be proactive. Use the “report” link on any comment that violates our comment policy.
Share with us. We'd love to hear your feedback.