<i>The Bachelor</i> Recap: And Then There Were Four

An inch of snow has fallen on Nashville, so naturally we’re all asking ourselves some hard questions: Will I survive this? Will I ever be able to leave my home again? Was 12 loaves of bread too many? What should I do with these 16 gallons of milk? Will anyone ever love me? While you contemplate the deep mysteries of existence, why not tune into The Bachelor? There is literally nothing else to be done in your life right now. This show is all you have left.

Before we dive into the episode, I’d like to acknowledge what’s been happening in Bachelor Nation over the past week or so. If you’re a person who actually has a life, you might not have heard what’s been going on off-screen this season. I have a little bit of a life (not much, but some) and I genuinely don't care about any of these people at all so I haven’t been paying that close attention either, but here’s the gist (I'm including a lot of links so you can read more about this yourself if you have the interest): In recent weeks, season frontrunner Rachael has been accused of racist and culturally inappropriate behavior and comments, including, but not limited to, bullying girls for dating black men, liking racist posts on social media, posting/promoting QAnon theories and Blue Lives Matter posts, and attending an antebellum party three years ago. An antebellum party is a thing that I just learned about where sororities and fraternities dress up as slave-owners and party at a plantation. Seriously. I have lived in the South off and on over the past 23 years, and it still manages to find new ways to surprise me with its aggressively racist traditions. Chris Harrison then defended this behavior to Rachel Lindsay — former Bachelorette and the franchise’s first Black lead — in the most arrogant, condescending, mansplainy way on her podcast. Many of the show’s previous and current BIPOC contestants issued statements about the franchise’s racist behaviors, Contestant Rachael finally issued an apology, Chris Harrison is now stepping down from the show for some indeterminate amount of time and Matt James is posting advertisements for Sam’s Club. If you want to read more about this, former contestant Sharleen wrote a detailed blog about it here.

On with last night’s episode. We left off last week right after Never Been Kissed Heather crashed the cocktail party and interrupted Matt’s time with Pieper. Never Been Kissed Heather tells Matt that she came to Pennsylvania because she is really attracted to his heart. I do believe his heart is what 800,000-plus Instagram followers hope to see in his posts each week. Heather’s BFF (and former Bachelorette) Hannah Brown, who has known Matt for a year or more, told her they could be a good match, so instead of just having her mutual friend introduce them back when they were both single, she decided to wait until he was halfway through filming a national television show to casually fly in and say hello. Matt seems giddy that she’s there, but tells her he wants time to think about it.

Meanwhile, Heather goes to introduce herself to the women. These ladies are tiny but their anger is big and I’m amazed they all fit on one little couch. The other ladies don’t even attempt to be polite. They want to know why she didn’t meet Matt before (fair question) and if she’s ready for marriage (LOL OK Dad). I’m not rooting for this Never Been Kissed woman, but it’s clear the other ladies learned nothing from last week’s Very Special Episode about bullying. Matt gazes out over the mountains as he considers this very complex dilemma before finally telling Heather that she showed up too late and he can’t keep her around. He walks her out and the other ladies are downright jubilant. On behalf of viewers everywhere, let me be the first to say “Thank you, ABC” for that 12 minutes of fabricated and completely unnecessary drama that you managed to stretch out over two episodes.

The women have never found Matt more attractive than they do after seeing him dump some random woman. He’s about to get a lot hotter because it’s Rose Ceremony time! Michelle and Pieper already have roses. The remaining roses go to Bri, Rachael, Serena P., Kit, Jessenia and Abigail. That means Runway Model Chelsea and Resident Mean Girl Serena C. are leaving.

One-on-One Date

Chris Harrison stops by the next morning to drop off the first date card. Abigail and Jessenia are the only two girls who haven’t had a one-on-one date yet, but the date card is actually for Serena P. She is thrilled to be going on a second date with Matt, but little does she know, Matt is using it as a chance to see if she can get out of the friend zone. Since everyone knows the best way to get out of the friend zone is by doing some sex poses in tight clothing, they spend the afternoon practicing tantric yoga. Fortunately, Matt does absolutely nothing with his life except work out and Serena only weighs about 65 lbs., so they make this look very easy. Serena, however, is very uncomfortable the whole time. At one point, Matt tries to kiss her and she makes a face and pulls away. Yikes! Afterward, as Matt is popping Champagne, he tells her how much he enjoyed it and she tells him how much she hated it. I think this train is leaving Friend Zone Station and heading swiftly to Acquaintanceville.

Their awkward, stilted, chemistry-less date continues over dinner, where they talk about family. Just when I think Matt is about to say farewell, he … gives a rose? Seriously, he does. I’m so confused. I like Serena but they seem like they’re just friends and not like friends who secretly want to make out. Just friends who don’t even like each other that much.

Group Date

Matt’s getting a quick workout in on his Peloton™ before his date with Pieper, Michelle, Rachael, Bri, Kit and Abigail. Whatever happens on this date isn’t interesting enough for primetime, so we just jump straight to the cocktail party. There is a lot of pressure riding on this date since it’s the last group date before it’s time to Meet the Families. Bri pulls Matt aside first and tells him that she quit her dream job a few days ago, but it was worth it to spend more time with Matt. Was it though? There’s no way Matt can dump her now. Well done, I guess. Who needs a dream job when you can get paid to hawk breakfast cereal online?

One after another, the ladies tell Matt how much they like him in hopes of securing a spot on the Hometown Dates episode. Abigail is feeling a lot of doubt and insecurity about her relationship with Matt. They had a strong connection on the first night — so much so that Matt gave her the First Impression Rose — but they’ve barely spent any time together since. She tells him that she can see a future with him, but she wants to know if he can see a future with her. He basically tells her that he’s not feeling it. As he explains it, he felt so strongly about her at first that he thought it would be wise to not spend any time with her at all in favor of getting to know the other women and, whaddya know, he ended up falling for the women he hung out with and not developing feelings for Abigail, the woman he was ignoring. What a surprising outcome. Usually I like people so much more when I don’t spend any time with them at all.

After Abigail’s departure, Rachael tearfully tells Matt how much she cares about him and that she’s been looking for this feeling her whole life. Matt reassures her that anytime he’s not with her, he’s thinking about her and she makes him smile. Meanwhile, Gossip Girl Kit sits him down and tells him that she needs to be honest with him. She tells him that there are certain non-negotiable things that he needs to know if he chooses her. First, she wants to finish school. LOL, she is still in college. Second, she wants to wait a long time to have kids. Like, until she’s 25 or 26. HAHAHAHA I wish I was kidding. Good luck having a baby at the ripe old age of 25, Kit. Hope your eggs don’t all dry up by then, grandma.

Ultimately, Matt gives the date rose to Rachael and leaves with her for a private concert with Aloe Blacc. Hey, a performer I’ve heard of before! Historic. Rachael and Matt slow-dance in a fancy ballroom while the other women literally cry together on their abandoned date. Bri says she feels like she could rip her own stomach out right now (is that a thing?), and Kit says she feels like someone just drove a dagger through her heart. At least no one is being overdramatic about the situation.

After Matt gets back to his room, Kit shows up at his door. She tells him that she’s falling in love with him, but that she doesn’t feel 100 percent about him so she thinks she should leave. Plus, you know, she’s missing summer camp for this and she's really been neglecting her duties as the president of the JoJo Siwa Fan Club so she’s gotta go.

One-on-One Date

The final date of the episode is a one-on-one with Jessenia. This date is every preteen boy’s dream — just peeling out and doing donuts around a parking lot in a souped-up muscle car. Jessenia seals the deal by making out with Matt on the hood of the car.

<i>The Bachelor</i> Recap: And Then There Were Four

At dinner, Jessenia — a woman we’ve never actually seen talk to Matt before — tells him that she’s falling in love with him. He responds by saying the six words every woman wants to hear: “Thank you for telling me that.” Not surprisingly, he sends her packing.

Rose Ceremony

It’s time for the final Rose Ceremony. The four women who get roses this week will introduce Matt to their families next week. Abigail, Kit and Jessenia have already left, and Rachael and Serena P. have roses. That leaves two roses and three women: Michelle, Pieper and Bri. Matt gives out the first rose to Bri. Before he gives out the second rose, Chris Harrison appears and announces that this is the final rose of the night. Thank you, Chris. How will this show ever go on without you? Matt gives the second — AND FINAL — rose to Michelle. That means Pieper is going home. Matt walks her to the car and she doesn’t say a word to him.

Like what you read?


Click here to become a member of the Scene !


Load comments