Tuesday, January 12, 2010
Education / Legislature / Politics / Woods As Special Session Begins, Teachers' Union Writhing in 'Indefensible Position'
Posted by Jeff Woods on Tue, Jan 12, 2010 at 5:23 PM
Bredesen's high-pressure gambit -- giving lawmakers one week to act, with hundreds of millions of dollars in federal money on the line -- puts the Tennessee Education Association in a nearly impossible position. Either the TEA caves and accepts legislation that's anathema to much of its membership, or the union looks like the villain in the loss of cash in the Obama administration's Race to the Top competition.
"We're in an indefensible position," one legislative friend of the TEA tells Pith.
Teachers are complaining about strong-arm tactics from the White House all the way down to the governor's office, but it won't do any good. Already, the TEA has made significant concessions that were unthinkable not long ago. First, the union agreed to accept changing state law to allow the use of student test scores in teacher evaluations and tenure decisions. Then, with Bredesen insisting that tests become the largest factor in evaluations, or at least 51 percent, the TEA offered to accept 35 percent. Now, it looks like the union will have to go along with the governor's plan to let the state Board of Education decide the issue. That's the same as letting Bredesen decide, since he appoints the board.
Bredesen's in such a strong position that he sounded almost smug when he talked about the TEA in his speech to the legislature tonight.
"To my very good friends at TEA and to all the wonderful teachers who are members of their local chapters across our state: we share a common goal -- to ensure that every child in Tennessee receives a year's worth of growth from a year's worth of instruction. Teachers matter: You bring something to this effort that no one else can. I invite you to join us."
He could have added, "or we will run right over you."
Comments (6)
Showing 1-6 of 6
Yep. Earl Wiman hasn't been looking too cheerful the last two days. The times, they are a-changin'.
like
dislike
It's about time. It's just too bad that the federal government had to make this come to a head in this state. Teachers should definitely be held accountable for grades their students receive. We are #3 from the BOTTOM in the USA for education. How bad can we get--to be last? If I don't do my job well, I will lose it. Shouldn't they? The gravy train is over with, and slackers should be held accountable. Tenure should be completely eliminated!
What? Parents and kids' inherent abilities aren't even in play here?
This is indefensible, and another nail in the Bredesen-killing-the-Democratic-Party-in-TN coffin.
I recall a fairly recent New Yorker story describing the "rubber rooms" in NYC where about 1000 tenured incompetent teachers spend the day reading, playing card etc while drawing their pay.
Eleanor,
For years the NEA and the AFT and their state and local unions have fought to insulate teachers from any sort of responsibility for the successes and failures of individual students and whole classes. That is why, as Kay Brooks has noted, it took 90 hours of hearings to remove one manifestly incompetent teacher.
All their victories have not improved Education so that now even traditional allies of the unions like the President, Governor Bredesen and Mayors like Daly and many more are abandoning them left and farther left.
Rather than blaming the Governor, you might ask why he is taking his position and why the President is taking his position.
It was 30 hours...but certainly seemed like 90.
http://kaybrooks.blogspot.com/2006/07/we-dismissed-teacher.html
