When I sat down to taste with Kim Stare Wallace of Sonoma County’s Dry Creek Vineyard, I told her that her winery’s recent email touting its 45th consecutive vintage of chenin blanc had inspired me to write about the grape. She smiled broadly. She seemed awfully happy about the prospect of making it into the Nashville Scene. Then she practically squealed, “Somebody actually reads our emails!”
Oh. OK. So maybe just knowing that her marketing dollars weren’t wasted is what delighted Kim, but she seemed genuinely excited about the milestone, too. Kim’s father, David Stare, founded Dry Creek Vineyard in 1972 with an affinity for France’s Loire Valley. He was the first to plant the Loire staple sauvignon blanc in Dry Creek Valley, and the vineyard’s unbroken chain of chenin production is remarkable, especially considering Americans’ obliviousness to the grape. Most people with awareness of chenin associate it with cheap and innocuous blends.
Chenin blanc suffers from what a frustrated American consumer might call obnoxious inconsistency. A more informed opinion might be that chenin boasts versatility. The wines can be fresh and fruity, nutty and oxidized, bone dry, sticky sweet, sparkling, still, supple or lean. The constant is high acidity, which leads to wines that when grown in cool climates, can be lean and austere. In warmer climates, that acidity steps up to balance the ripeness of the grape. It’s safe to say that if you like chardonnay, Fino sherry, Champagne, riesling or Sauternes, then there is some iteration of chenin blanc that will please you. The sheer breadth of styles became plain after I shopped for wines for this column, with more styles of chenin than I could cover.
Of the catholic range of chenin blanc produced in the Loire Valley, Vouvray is easiest to love, and usually the easiest to acquire. Dry, sparkling and sticky-sweet versions are available, but some version of an off-dry (the label might read demi-sec) Vouvray will likely turn up. Be aware that the French tend to use the word sec (dry) to describe varying degrees of sweetness — only after the wines have crossed into sticky sweetness do they actually deign to use the word sweet (moelleux or doux). Only the word sec, standing alone, indicates true dryness.
The Vouvray from Vigneau-Chevreau is classic: pale gold, with mouth-coating sweetness and a finish like biting into a honey-dipped lemon. Though rosé seems to have aggressively claimed the warmer months, this is an incredibly refreshing wine that is made for drinking when the weather is hot.
If Vouvray is the friend with whom you hit it off immediately, Savennières is the one who rubbed you the wrong way at first. The headline for Eric Asimov’s 2014 article in The New York Times uses a questionable mantle — the thinking person’s white wine — to convey a broad truth: Savennières is short on easy pleasures. The wines are almost always bone-dry, and the attractive fruit aromas of Vouvray are supplanted by citrus pith and the nuttiness that indicates oxidation. Five years of mellowing are helpful, if not necessary, and a little air can’t hurt either. I’ve read that Nicolas Joly, the famed Savennières grower and producer, recommends opening the wine two or so days before drinking. Seriously.
Where I work, for every four bottles of Château d’Épiré Savennières that go out, one is sent back. As with mezcal and sea urchin, even an exhaustive explanation and earnest nods of understanding don’t guarantee a patron’s enjoyment; the only sure bets are those who already know what they’re getting into. Indeed, the only time I tasted Joly’s famous Clos de la Coulée de Serrant Savennières was a decade ago when the wine was sent back from a table. My boss tasted the wine, then shook his head as he told the server to bring the diner something else. “That’s just the wine,” he grumbled, annoyed. At the end of the night, we drained the waxy, wooly bottle. Maybe that New York Times headline was right: Ten years later, I am still thinking about that wine.
The Château d’Épiré is an excellent way to dip your toe into the world of dry white wines with some age and real personality. It’s not for everyone, but you have to take a chance every so often. The wine is deep gold, with butterscotch and hazelnut aromas filling the glass. Fuller-bodied, it finishes with bracing acid and bitter citrus. Although d’Épiré is not his wine, Joly may be onto something: Some 40 hours after being opened, the wine is better than ever.
If Savennières is for the contemplative man, the Dry Creek chenin is for the carefree bon vivant: a crisp, dry white that is great on its own, with light dishes, or with Asian food. Wallace doesn’t know exactly when her father forsook North Coast chenin for the Wilson family’s Clarksburg fruit, but the decision was prescient: The Clarksburg American Viticultural Area has now cemented itself as California’s top chenin site, producing wines with distinctive melon characteristics.
Produced with dry Vouvray in mind, this chenin blanc is at odds with the previously mentioned Vouvray (not as sweet) and the Savennières (not as baffling/challenging). Dry Loire whites are ideal with seafood, and the Dry Creek chenin has won the Pacific Coast Oyster Wine Competition so many times that other entrants might wonder why they bother showing up. This is another ideal warm-weather wine: the Vouvray without a touch of sugar.
Having struck out on a South African chenin blanc, I found a Washington chenin from Merriman that, like Joly’s Savennières, came with counterintuitive drinking instructions: I was to drink it at cellar temperature — too warm for white wine, most would say. I gamely played along. I tasted the wine intermittently as it warmed out of the fridge, and the aromas filled out the glass more and more robustly. Chenin’s telltale woolliness, that warm smell that recalls a rained-upon sweater, was front and center. This wine had the most body of them all: Now nearly at room temperature, it displayed mouthfeel of the demi-sec Vouvray, with none of the sugar. Still chenin. The same but different. A most versatile grape, whether you want to think about it or not.
Email arts@nashvillescene.com


Post a comment as anonymous
Report
Watch this discussion.
(0) comments
Welcome to the discussion.
Log In
Welcome to the discussion.
Keep it clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or otherwise abusive language. Comments featuring hate speech or threatening or violent content will not be tolerated.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Be truthful. Don't knowingly lie or mislead.
Be proactive. Use the “report” link on any comment that violates our comment policy.
Share with us. We'd love to hear your feedback.