First, owners Tara and Dave Tieman and Tanner Jacobs spent a year formulating a dough recipe. Well, no — first the Tiemans spent 12 years as attorneys. Then they looked around their East Nashville neighborhood and said, “What would we be really excited to see open here?” Came the answer: pizza by the slice.
They then spent a year renovating the former bike shop at 1012 Woodland St. When they weren't renovating or overseeing renovation, they were working on the recipe for crust. Different combinations of flour and water, different water, different flour, rise times — there are dozens of variables to test. They consulted bakers, researched online, and spent a week working at a pizzeria on Staten Island, N.Y.
And then there was sauce. Oh, and the beer permit. I don’t need to tell you that was a nightmare. Both Tiemans went through the application over and over, yet with their combined 24 years in practice, they couldn’t figure out how to fill out the application. In the end, they got their beer license, and Tara Tieman is helping the Metro Beer Board overhaul its permit application form, which should gladden many prospective restaurant owners.
The Five Points crew originally envisioned being BYOB, since Woodland Wines is across the street. But in Nashville, things are not so simple. That beer permit turned out to be a mixed blessing: It allows them to serve beer, but not to serve or allow any other alcohol — including BYOB. So now they’re working toward the limited license that will allow them to sell wine and high-gravity beer.
It all turns out to have been worth it — for the diner, anyway. The focus really is on pizza. The menu contains a couple of salads and a fantastic antipasto platter, but everything else is pizza. The Epic Crust Quest yielded a thinnish crust that's crisp when you bite into it, with a satisfyingly chewy texture. A mere hint of sauce, just enough for flavor, just the way I prefer it. The Greek pizza was strewn with red onion crescents, fresh tomato slices, generous feta chunks, banana pepper rings and black olives, all so fresh they still had their vibrant, just-cut flavors.
So now that you know Five Points Pizza, won't it be great to check it out IRL?
Five Points Pizza is at 1012 Woodland St. (915-4174). For now they are offering dine-in service only, but will add takeout in the next few weeks. Watch for updates on their Facebook page. Hours: 11 a.m.-midnight Sunday, Monday, Wednesday and Thursday; 11 a.m.-2 a.m. Friday and Saturday. Closed Tuesdays.