For the past two years running, we've celebrated a friend's birthday at Goten on West End. This effervescent lady has close friends coming out of the woodwork--childhood friends, college friends, graduate school friends, work friends and friends of friends--so the place does make sense for a big group. Last year I remember it being a relatively pleasant experience where good times were had by all. This year, I had fun, but left kind of sad and frustrated in the food department.
Now, I know people don't eat hibachi for the complex flavors--they go for the razzle-dazzle of flipping knives, flying shrimp and whimsical steam volcanoes made from onions--but this was something else. There was a level of laziness to the proceedings that was borderline offensive. The "soup" was a weak consomme--think salted pasta water--with a couple raw button mushroom slices bobbing sadly on top. We were served small dishes of soy sauce and "Japanese ketchup"--shit tasted like Heinz and I wouldn't have put it anywhere near my "fish or vegetables" as the waitress suggested. And our chef barely interacted, cooking the food in a workmanlike manner while spraying steam in a bunch of people's faces.
I ordered tofu, and the curd itself was quite nice, but the sauce was a sticky, sweet afterthought. The fried rice was bland and overpriced. And, after the meal came the coup de grâce: "dessert"--a sad little scoop of store-bought orange sherbet.
(In Goten's defense, the one person at the table who ordered sushi thoroughly enjoyed their meal.)
OK, OK. I realize how I must sound. And I know, again, that people don't really go to this place for the food, but when the final indecency--the check!--came, I couldn't stifle a groan. For one drink and enough sodium to replenish the Dead Sea, my tab came to almost $30 (and I ordered one of the cheapest things on the menu). A companion whispered to me: "We could have gone to City House for this price. And drunk a bunch of wine!"
Maybe the funniest part is that I'm sure I'll be back next year.
Showing 1-2 of 2
There's an old saying in Tennessee — I know it's in Texas, probably in Tennessee — that says, fool me once, shame on — shame on you. Fool me — you can't get fooled again.
Wait, aren't you also going to share the joys of the atmosphere? The table of at least twenty teenagers doing sake bombs right behind us? No?
In his defense, I think that chef could tell that we weren't in it for the showoffiness. He tried a few fancy tricks at the beginning (a rather weak onion volcano) and didn't even get a flutter of applause. I think he gave up after that.
But yeah, I guess we weren't there for the food. Good thing.